Comparison · Comparisons

Best WordPress Analytics Plugins, and When to Skip the Plugin

Site Kit, MonsterInsights, Jetpack Stats, privacy-first plugins and a plain script compared for WordPress, with what each costs in speed and privacy.

· 3 min read

Two comparison cards beside the DataFair mark

WordPress has an analytics plugin for every taste. Most fall into three groups: plugins that bring Google Analytics into your dashboard, plugins that store stats in your own database, and lightweight privacy-first plugins. Sometimes the best option is no plugin at all.

Group 1: Google Analytics inside WordPress

Site Kit by Google is Google's official plugin. It connects GA4, Search Console and other Google services and shows summaries in your WordPress dashboard. Free.

MonsterInsights is a popular GA plugin with friendlier reports, ecommerce tracking and form tracking in its paid tiers.

Good for: sites already committed to GA4 and Google Ads. Watch out for: GA4 needs a consent banner in many countries, and visitors who decline aren't counted. GA4 and GDPR.

Group 2: stats stored in your database

Jetpack Stats, WP Statistics and Independent Analytics count visits and show them inside WordPress.

Good for: owners who want everything in WP admin. Watch out for: stats tables grow, and heavy queries can slow down busy sites. Check each plugin's licence and pricing for commercial sites.

Group 3: privacy-first plugins and scripts

Plugins such as Burst Statistics focus on privacy-friendly counting, and hosted tools like Plausible, Fathom and Umami offer WordPress plugins or a simple script.

Good for: sites that want to avoid cookie banners for analytics. How cookieless analytics works.

Option 4: skip the plugin

Every plugin is code that runs on your server and needs updating. Many hosted analytics tools need only one script tag in your theme's header. Add it with your theme's settings, a child theme, or a small "insert headers" plugin you probably already have. Reports live on the analytics provider's servers, not your database.

DataFair works this way:

<script defer data-website-id="YOUR_WEBSITE_ID" src="https://datafair.dev/js/script.js"></script>

Add data-cookieless to store nothing in visitors' browsers.

Which to pick

You wantPick
GA4 and Google AdsSite Kit or MonsterInsights
Stats inside WP adminA database stats plugin, on a site with modest traffic
No cookie banner for analyticsA privacy-first plugin or hosted script
Revenue by traffic sourceA revenue analytics tool

If you sell with WooCommerce, or take payments through Stripe, Lemon Squeezy or PayPal from a WordPress site, the question that matters is which traffic brings paying customers. DataFair connects to those providers by webhook and shows revenue next to every source and page. The WooCommerce version of this guide.

Revenue by landing page in DataFair
Pages with revenue in the DataFair demo (sample data).

Related guide: A Google Analytics alternative built around revenue.

Questions

What is the best free WordPress analytics plugin?
Site Kit by Google is free and official if you use GA4. Several privacy-first and database stats plugins have free versions; check their limits.
Do analytics plugins slow down WordPress?
They can, especially plugins that store and query stats in your database. A hosted script loaded with defer has little effect on page speed.
Can I track WordPress analytics without a plugin?
Yes. Paste your analytics script into your theme's header or use a headers plugin.

Related